Female Sterilization

Female surgical sterilization (also called tubal sterilization, tubal ligation, and tubal occlusion) is a low-risk, highly effective one-time procedure that offers lifelong protection against pregnancy. About 700,000 women undergo this procedure each year in the United States.

Basics of Female Sterilization
Female surgical sterilization procedures block the fallopian tubes and thereby prevents sperm from reaching and fertilizing the eggs. The ovaries continue to function normally, but the eggs they release break up and are harmlessly absorbed by the body. Tubal sterilization is performed in a hospital or outpatient clinic under local or general anesthesia.

The uterus is a hollow muscular organ located in the female pelvis between the bladder and rectum. The ovaries produce the eggs that travel through the fallopian tubes. Once the egg has left the ovary it can be fertilized and implant itself in the lining of the uterus. The main function of the uterus is to nourish the developing fetus prior to birth.

Sterilization does not cause menopause. Menstruation continues as before, with usually very little difference in length, regularity, flow, or cramping. (One study suggested that women with a history of Cesarean section may experience slightly heavier bleeding.) Sterilization does not offer protection against sexually transmitted diseases.

Specific Tubal Sterilization Techniques
Laparoscopy. Laparoscopy is the most common surgical approach for tubal sterilization:

The procedure begins with a tiny incision in the abdomen in or near the navel. The surgeon inserts a narrow viewing scope called a laparoscope through the incision.
A second small incision is made just above the pubic hairline, and a probe is inserted.

Once the tubes are found, the surgeon closes them using different methods: clips, tubal rings, or electrocoagulation (using an electric current to cauterize and destroy a portion of the tube).

Laparoscopy usually takes 20 - 30 minutes and causes minimal scarring. The patient is often able to go home the same day and can resume intercourse as soon as she feels ready.

Minilaparotomy. Minilaparotomy does not use a viewing instrument and requires an abdominal incision, but it is small -- about 2 inches long. The tubes are tied and cut. Generally speaking, minilaparotomy is preferred for women who choose to be sterilized right after childbirth, while laparoscopy is preferred at other times. Minilaparotomy usually takes approximately 30 minutes to perform. Women who undergo minilaparotomy typically need a few days to recover and can resume intercourse after consulting their doctor.

Laparotomy. Laparotomy, a less common approach, requires an extensive 2- to 5-inch incision in the abdomen. It is considered major surgery and can require a hospital stay of a few days followed by recovery at home for several weeks. Resumption of intercourse depends on how quickly one is able to recover.

Culdoscopy. Culdoscopy involves inserting a scope through the vagina and into the pelvic cavity. Although it is less invasive than laparoscopy, a major 2002 analysis reported that it has a higher complication rate than either laparoscopy or minilaparotomy.

Essure. Approved in 2002, the Essure method uses a small spiral-like device to block the fallopian tube. Unlike tubal ligation, the Essure procedure does not require incisions or general anesthesia. It can be performed in a doctor’s office and takes about 45 minutes. A specially trained doctor uses a viewing instrument called a hysteroscope to insert the device through the vagina and into the uterus, and then up into the fallopian tube. Once the device is in place, it expands inside the fallopian tubes. During the next 3 months, scar tissue forms around the device and blocks the tubes. This results in permanent sterilization.

Candidacy for Female Sterilization
Before undergoing sterilization, a woman must be sure that she no longer wants to bear children and will not want to bear children in the future, even if the circumstances of her life change drastically. She must also be aware of the many effective contraceptive choices available. Possible reasons for choosing female sterilization procedures over reversible forms of contraception include:

Not wanting children and being unable to use other methods of contraception
Health problems that make pregnancy unsafe

Genetic disorders
If married, both partners should completely agree that they no longer want to have children and should also have ruled out vasectomy for the man. Vasectomy is a simple procedure that has a lower failure rate than female surgical sterilization, carries fewer risks, and is less expensive. [See In-Depth Report #37: Vasectomy.]

Even if all these factors are present, a woman must consider her options carefully before proceeding. Studies report that over time, 14 - 25% of women eventually regret this choice. Women at highest risk for regretting sterilization include:

Women who are younger at the time of sterilization. In one long-term study, over 40% of women who had had tubal ligation between the ages of 18 - 24 regretted their choice. (Only about 4% of women over 35 had these regrets.)

Women who had the procedure immediately after a vaginal delivery.
Women who had the procedure within 7 years of having their youngest child.
Women in lower income groups.

If a woman changes her mind and wants to become pregnant, a reversal procedure is available, but it is very difficult to perform and requires an experienced surgeon. Subsequent pregnancy rates after reversal are between 20 - 84%, depending on the surgical skill, the age of the woman, and, to a lesser degree, her weight and the length of time between the tubal ligation and the reversal procedure. Not all insurance carriers cover the cost of reversal.

Advantages of Female Sterilization
Women who choose sterilization no longer need to worry about pregnancy or cope with the distractions and possible side effects of contraceptives. Sterilization does not impair sexual desire or pleasure, and many people say that it actually enhances sex by removing the fear of unwanted pregnancy. There is some evidence it may help reduce the risk for ovarian cancer.

Disadvantages and Complications of Female Sterilization
Failure is rare, but about 1 in 200 women become pregnant during the first year after sterilization, and failure rate can rise to 5% after 10 years. About a third of these pregnancies are ectopic, which require surgical treatment.

After any of the procedures, a woman may feel tired, dizzy, nauseous, bloated, or gassy, and may have minor abdominal and shoulder pain. In general, there is more postoperative pain with the tubal ring than with electrocoagulation.

Serious complications from female surgical sterilization are rare and are most likely to occur with abdominal procedures. They include bleeding, infection, or reaction to the anesthetic. On rare occasions the bowels or blood vessels are injured and require major surgical repair. The use of electrocoagulation poses a risk for burns in the small intestine and may increase the risk for menstrual disorders afterward.